The Option To Gamble On Higher Stock Prices

How ludicrous are current stock prices? Consider the following charts:

Traditional Indicators.

Four prominent measures—PE10, Crestmont PE, Q Ratio, Regression—have collectively catapulted more than 3 standard deviations above a mean. The average of the four (172%) has even eclipsed 2000’s infamous stock bubble (164%).

Average Of The 4 Valuation IndicatorsAverage Of The 4 Valuation Indicators

And that’s not all. Nearly every traditional measure is sitting at the highest valuation levels in US history.

S&P 500 ValuationsS&P 500 Valuations

Citigroup’s Panic-Euphoria Indicator.

This measure combines a host of greed-fear indicators, including options trading, margin debt as well as bull-bear sentiment. Once again, investors haven’t been this “cuckoo for Cocoa Puffs” since the dot-com tech bubble burst in 2000.

Panic-Euphoria ModelPanic-Euphoria Model

Theory of Relativity

When investors are inclined to speculate, they tend to chase growth stocks. When investors are looking for beaten-down bargains, they tend to focus on undervalued stocks for the longer-term. Today? What investors are paying for growth stocks versus what they’re paying for value stocks is eerily reminiscent of 2000’s stock bubble.

Growth vs Value Relative ValuationGrowth vs Value Relative Valuation

Nearly everywhere one looks, the absurdity of stock pricing in 2020 rhymes with what occurred just 20 years ago. Yet participants remain unfazed.

Is this time actually different?

Let’s take a look at call option demand. Investors buy calls when they expect stock prices to rise. Similarly, sellers of call options often cover positions by buying underlying stocks, putting additional upward pressure on price.

To what extent are folks betting on prices to keep increasing? Today’s speculative folly is far more extreme than 2000’s irrational exuberance.

OPCVTOC IndexOPCVTOC IndexOriginal Article

Leave a comment

Send a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *